Відео

再聊文明，偶然看到一个没正经念过书某博主直播，他和观众聊某文明古国到底什么水平，随口一说，让我觉得他这个天然朴素的认知远超许多读书读傻了的网友，他大概说，就看建国后几十年那些运动，搞死的那些人，和这些年的亲身经历，就知道在现当代，这个地方都那副德行，还吹什么古代如何如何，你现代吃上饭了牛b了都这样，古代吃不上饭还觉得自己能更牛b？我哈哈一笑，这不是个可以具体分析的案例，因为被教育过的人总会用辩证法找反例挑毛病，这只是讲了一个道理：愚昧都是后天教育出来的，族群也是，历史越长，反而还不如原始部落直接进入现代社会，因为一张白纸没有多余的学习成本。

秦晖老师的水平自不待言，但他有许多中国学者的一个通病，就是对西方学者的盲目贬低，这种情况在不通外文的中国学者中尤甚。我本科时就选修过秦老师的课，说句不客气的话他的英文水平基本停留在中学阶段，而且是文革时期的中学水平，接触西方学术成果只能依赖少得可怜且质量堪忧的中译本，根本没有能力接触到最前沿最精深的作品，他的作品中也几乎从不直接引用外文文献，他对东欧和俄罗斯的了解也完全依赖夫人的二手知识。虽然对不明就里的人来说他的学问深不可测，但如果你恰巧是某个领域的研究者，很容易发现他的知识漏洞百出而且过时。比如他所说的什么一个问题难倒西方学界这种逸闻，每个中国学者都有自己的版本，可你想想，一个专门研究科举的学者会不知道基本名词如“乡试”、“举人”的来源吗？究竟是西方学术标准严格还是中国人治学严谨，内行人自然清楚。

开头的湾湾和美丽国是不是助手在乱操作？对两个民主国家的蔑称是秦晖的讲稿？

“客套话我就不多说了” 竟然能翻译成 I'm not being polite. I'm not saying many polite words. 这个软件太差了。 应该是I'll skip the pleasantries

问好秦晖老师！感谢您开启民智的不懈努力！❤

thank you professor qin

秦老师真是大学者风范

秦老师应该跟美国人交流下关于全球化的看法

得民心者得天下，和现代民主可是差了十万八千里。得民心者得天下讲还是为民做主，其主体依然是统治者。现代民主追求的，是民为主体，官员只是人民的意志派生者。

乡愿只老好人，不敢得罪人。墙头草没错，但倒不一定是唯上的人，如果基层势力大，也会倒向基层。

❤

真牛逼，文科被鄙视不是没道理的，意识形态这么浓重。这哪是讲历史，这是宗教，一个虔诚的西方文明信徒。

现在的权力，已经下放到乡镇边缘人的手上了。这种边缘人，在大城市无法立足，在小乡村不够本分，但够“不忘初心”，“牢记使命”

欧洲是王权跟市民联合走出贵族制，走向民主！答案很明显了：天朝就是老大联合平民，反对党权，实行宪政，而是不是闹革命，制度化的目的就是反官倒、反商倒。左派增加社会福利，右派限制政府权力，一左一右，达成协议，进行宪政！秦晖教授，如果没有说明的是如今中国，没有皇权架构，没有秦制的实质。在现代政治的皮表中隐含着深刻专制遗毒，这种遗毒就是斯大林体制特权，还有就是逃避罪责，正如陈云所说“我们共产党坏事做得太好了，一旦失去权力，杀共产党会成疯！”这句话对邓小平，包括后世领导人，产生深刻影响！

那我要去拜访他

Barry, keep crying.LOL.

秦教授该看看《圣殿春秋》，也许可以改变一下所谓西方社会“无酷吏”的看法。

游记

Huawei has been doomed… … 😂

UCSD这场的录制最好👍

感谢分享啊

秦老师在费正清研究所做访问学者，真是活到老学到老。❤祝安康，我们需要您。

秦晖老师又开讲了😢

秦教授最后一个问题，避重就轻了，人家问的是：尽管少数时期中国有追求文明的时刻，但2000多年来中华有文明吗？秦教授先是转移话题，把问题归结成，周制以来文明倒退论。但人家压根没提中国古代文明是否倒退，而是来求证中国古代是否能叫做有文明。后面干脆开始心灵鸡汤，说文明是偶发的，有先后，不能说英国文明了，中国就不可能文明了，这是哪跟哪儿呀？那是不是没见过文明社会，中国连文明是什么都不知道，更何况有没有，还是说东方文明和世界定义不同，某些概念要区分某地专用和世界常识。最后更是缴械投降，说这个问题没有意义，哈哈哈，可以理解您是一辈子研究历史的，舍不得，或者有其他顾虑。但否定自己研究对象不会失去什么，反而更能接近真相。这种定性、下结论的话，还是让网友来回答吧：根本没有文明，3300多年一共就末期断断续续文明了小几十年，且还是局部，谁也不好意思管这叫文明。说这个问题没意义，无疑是自己打脸、心灵鸡汤，企图幻想未来某一天该地文明了，又可以“自古以来”了，类似高考了十几年，想着哪一天考上清华了，就可以吹牛自己从小学习成绩就好一样。

秦晖老师

Can you ad the transcript?

I am happy to find this site when I was searching for the details of the book on Shinkansen by Prof. Abel. My husband, Yoshiharu Takamatsu, worked for all the Shinkansen projects and wrote books on it and Japanese railways.

I think you guys have no brain to learn india. india change very quik just wait and see.🤑🤑🤑

37:17 when you can go to Beijing for a blue sky day like this every day? Don’t know much about universities, but certainly Chairman Xi will be delighted to hear this talk. It’s really the West declining and China rising !

I agree with Mr.Kennedy about American first mover advantage; however China has tremendous potential and energy, it can achieve more if it can become more open and devote into arts and cultural diversity. History had demonstrated China‘s dominance for thousands years and it is ontrack to re-emerge its premminance again.

China has tremendous potential and energy, it can achieve more if it can become more open and devote into arts and cultural diversity.

With less than 7 years remaining in the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) challenge focusing on students and young professionals gaining entry ways to do the mapping and spatial analysis research of issues and problems confronting humanity is very important

I actually cannot express how genuinely criminaly underated this video actually is and this world actually genuinely needs more people actually like him in this world and this is actually the actual real China that the actual American and British BBC propaganda mainstream media actually don't show you is actually really like and actually capable of actually doing.

watching Top USA leads talking about China is like watching a child talking about adult.

Bedrasticactionsoncotrolglobalwarmingspollutionsdeforestsonearth😅highactionsonjust

He started out as a gentleman, then all of a sudden turned into a crazy rant in the middle of it... Like it was triggeres by some anti C vaccine. What a barking show...

Any one in any Democracy should read this book. Thomas Jefferson said "Freedom requires constant vigil"

Xi may not be perfect, but at least he can find his way on & off the podium. 🤣🤣🤣🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦

I fail to gather what i have learnt from this.

Informative and interesting reports about Chinese Companies that the US can emulate to improve the lives of Americans instead of wasting taxpayers money on futile wars.

He does need to make a living by continuing feeding the higher ups what they want to hear.

Go CHINA!!!

CIA propaganda channel 😂😂😂

If Xi and his team are so bad, how can Xi proposed "Made in China 2025", which accomplished 86% of goal already, and In Xi's reign, China GDP has grown 40%... good luck

What a waste of 30 minutes. Another self acclaimed "China expert" with a shallow analysis, clouded by political bias and conversations with a "couple of guys" he met on his on a 14 day trip to China. And oh, did he mention, he went on a trip to China.

I feel sorry for the Americans, for the audiences. If we continue to live in a well then we will never feel the need to improve.

.

What poppycock expert is this guy? Let him spread disinformation! To the detriment of the gullible who believe in all the falsehoods.

Have yet to see a household famous Chinese consumer brand in the West. BYD’s representative on a recent Bloomberg interview was a flop, she has zero global awareness, which was painful to watch. BYD is supposed to be hot and she is all they got, not a confidence builder for Chinese business in general

Scott Kennedy may be very good at understanding technology but shows total ignorance of how China is governed, their approach to problem-solving and Xi Jinping. He fails to understand that China is again in a period of transition from rapid growth to slower growth. To avoid the "middle-income trap" and solve the associated new problems using pragmatic rather than ideological ways. It is a problem that was anticipated about 10 years ago, so it was not a surprise. At the same time, they have to manage the increasing US economic and military (Taiwan) aggression.